Skip to main content
Summary:Discussing Eva Herman's book "The Eva Principle"... and not her other recent controversy...
I don’t have a television in my apartment – so needless to say I eat a lot of meals with my latest Economist edition, a reading from class, or listening to talk radio. Sometimes though the commentators and moderators speak to quickly for me to understand what is going on, or I just don’t understand the background of an issue and so have a hard time following.
Eating by myself has never been more confusing.
Last week, on the radio there was a lot of fuss about a woman named Eva Herman and her appearance on a recent German television talk-show. Herman I’ve discovered made some comments, specifics of which can be found by reading this Spiegel Online article. I want to focus more on her book – which is just as controversial as her recent most recent debacle.
In her book the " Eva Principle," Herman argues that if German feminists don't change their ways against the backdrop of a greying population, the country will die out.
Essentially she wants women in the home, baking cookies and making babies. Or as Spiegel goes on to say, she advocated for, “Motherhood instead of emancipation, child-rearing instead of career-climbing, devoted marriage instead of egoistic self-fulfillment”.
Having just now read the synopsis of her book, I’m more than a little stunned.
And, also, quite frankly, speechless.
I never thought of myself as a feminist, but she sure makes me want to start spending my time fighting harder for women’s rights, and universal childcare and a more equal mindset when it comes to men participating in child-rearing. Germany, and other countries struggling with low birth rates, could solve this problem, perhaps not by setting the women’s movement back by 50 years like Herman suggests but by changing the society’s mindset. It should be okay that woman work and have children; it should be okay for men to stay at home and take maternity leave, and there should be institutions and mechanisms that support families, financially and other ways.
Anyone else a little stunned?
2 Comments
Jamie Manzer
I find the phrase 'I never thought of myself as a feminist but...' extremely problematic—not so much in the context of your blog but in its usage within a wider societal context. The use of the phrase implies that women and frankly, anyone arguing on behalf of women, must first preface their argument suggesting ‘oh but wait, I do have something rational (worthy, too, perhaps?) to say.’ Why are arguments defending the basic equal of rights of women considered extreme? And why are arguments that seem extreme considered irrational (or unworthy)? Growing up in an extremely patriarchical society in the rural United States, whenever I refused to hoo-ha with men who insisted on demoralizing or demonizing women, I became the aggressor—the person who overstepped a cultural boundary and ultimately, the person who was abraded for defending my basic rights.
As such, I agree, we are up against a constructed mindset. A motherly version of feminism has become accepted and institutionalized (within policies)—i.e. the policy concerning ‘maternity leaves’ implies that these leaves are only available for women. Unfortunately, old fashioned mindsets create old fashioned policies and old fashioned policies legitimate gender biases like those promulgated by Eva Herman.
meka4996 meka4996
Same job same pay, no problem, but...
If you believe in Bible, you would be aware of who is the first human, who is the second human, and why...
If you don't, then you would be aware there can ONLY BE ONE leader in any group of people (country, community, company, family), and why...
How can two people make one decision? How?
by working things out? How?
Have so many married couple worked things out? Have they???
If you believe current divorce rates are not high enough, or birth rate are not low enough, or women are much happier working outside than the thought of taking care of her men/children inside, or a stay at home wife/mother is worth less than a professional career womon, then I don't know what to say...
Is feminism based on competing with men? be as good as men?
Is there love in competition? Is there love in "I can do better"?
Is there feminine beauty in a woman trying to prove herself in money making? ...
How cruel can a competition be? Why would a man care for his wife if she is in competition with him? Can you?